Add Your Review

Thanks for visiting Bagel Boss Hicksville. We'd love to have your feedback!

Bagel Boss Hicksville

Type to search our menu...

You are submitting your information to Bagel Boss Hicksville and Popmenu, which powers this site and is sponsoring this giveaway. Popmenu's and apply.

Our Latest Reviews

Lenny&Shelley 9 days ago

Mini Bagels (Dozen)

Best Mini Bagels we've found. We live in Maryland and whenever we're on Long Island, which is often since we have family there, we go to Bagel Boss. And not just for Mini Bagels. Their Black & White cookies rock. We buy the smaller ones so we don't over indulge, but we love them.

Bennit6 17 days ago

Bagels / Bialys

Great bagels! Amazing taste and texture

Reb 18 days ago

Bagel & Butter

We loved it here! We got some delicious bagels and cream cheese and to enjoy and some juice to drink. They have so many options to choose from we could spend the whole day eating there! Can't wait to go back!

Rozanne 30 days ago

1 piece Grilled Teriyaki Salmon

Delicious and filling

Marisadaniellecorbett about 2 months ago

All Tuna Salads (Bagel or Wrap)

Bagel boss i awesome! Been coming here for 10 years now! Service and food are great and so is Pual!!! Thanks bagel boss!

Debra 10 days ago

Matzo Ball Soup

Best of the best!! Soup, service plus a free bagel w butter!! I love this place!! Everything is always exceptional!!

Payamgil 18 days ago

Bagel with Cream Cheese

One of the best bagels that I've had, period. The bagel was so fresh and the perfect toast! The cream cheese was creamy and cold just the way I like it. We came from a far distance because we heard how good their bagels are, and it won't be the last ???

Chsubhan76 22 days ago

Bagel & Butter


Filzaasad91 about 1 month ago

Bagels / Bialys

Best bagels in the town! So fresh and flavorful!

Rebecca 2 months ago

Bagels / Bialys

Bagel Boss bagels are THE BEST bagels!! I have lived on LI for over 30 years and have been going to the Hicksville location since I am 10! Even though I live in Suffolk now, i still come to Hicksville when I want my egg everything as nothing beats it!!